Extra Anejo Tequila

Today we take a deep dive into the most premium expression in tequila – the extra anejo!  As I've covered on other parts of this website, there is a city in Mexico by the name of Tequila located in the highlands of the state of Jalisco.

Few people know the history of tequila, the intricate and subtle complexity of a fine sipping tequila, or even that it can be used to create diamonds! The most subtle of all knowledge regarding this unique spirit involves the way and length of time for which it is aged. The best tequilas with the most sophisticated undertones are aged in wood barrels, such as oak. Often the barrels will have been used previously to age some other variety of alcohol … whiskey, scotch, even wine. Tequila that has been aged for at least three years is called Extra Anejo Tequila.

My List of the Best Extra Anejo Tequilas of 2021!

How Extra Anejo Tequila is Made

The farming of the blue agave plant, it's planting, tending and harvest remain today largely as a hand-me-down from earlier generations that did all plant cultivation by hand. The secrets to producing great agave plants are passed down in an oral tradition from father to son. The plant is trimmed to prevent flowering in order for its energy to go into the production of its characteristic blue-green leaves. The workers are able to test the plants to tell when they're ready to harvest by peeling back the leaves from the plant's core with a special circular blade affixed to a long pole. The plant's core, or piña, must be harvested at exactly the right time to have the necessary carbohydrates for fermentation. A piña is likely to weigh as much as 150 pounds.

Once they are harvested, the piñas are baked in slow ovens to turn their starches into sugar. Then large stone wheels are used to break down the piñas, shredding and mashing them. The pulp is left behind and used for other purposes, such as animal feed or compost. The extracted juice is placed into a vat to ferment. The results from this first cycle of fermenting is called mosto or wort. The second time the juice is fermented, the resulting product is called silver tequila, because it is clear. This silver tequila is either bottled or alternately, pumped into wooden barrels to age into either resposado or extra anejo tequila. Extra anejo tequila has a far mellower and more complex flavor than tequila that was bottled immediately, and will be golden amber in color.

Not only is it possible for the discriminating palette to note the complexities provided by the wooden cask, but it also possible for him to note the differences in tequila made from both highland and lowland agave plants. Agave grown in higher altitudes tends to be sweeter whereas that grown in the lower altitudes is earthier. Blanco tequila is a white spirit that which was either aged for less than two months, if at all. It frequently is bottled immediately after distillation. Joven is blanco that was flavored and colored with caramel. Tequila that is aged for at least two months, but less than a year is called resposado. Most of today's Extra Anejo Tequila came from 100% pure agave plants that took 10-12 years to mature the plant's sugars and which was then aged for a bare minimum of three years or longer, after which it is re-distilled and usually diluted with distilled water to achieve the desired concentration. Today there are over a hundred distilleries in Mexico that together make more than 900 brands of tequila. In 2006, the Tequila Trade Agreement proposed that all tequila be bottled in Mexico before being permitted to leave the country.

Extra Anejo Tequila Reviews

Check out my growing library of extra anejo tequila reviews:

What Makes Extra Anejo Tequila Unique?

Extra anejo tequila, often referred to as “ultra-aged,” is a favorite of tequila connoisseurs everywhere. The category officially came into existence in the summertime of 2006, when a brand new Norma Oficial Mexicana was issued that created an all new category for tequila that was aged for a minimum of three years. In order to qualify as extra anejo, the tequila must be aged for a minimum of three years in either wooden barrels or other containers that have a maximum capacity of 600 liters. Different manufacturers jealously hoard their own unique secrets as to exactly how and in what they age their extra anejo tequila. For example, some will age the tequila in barrels that previously held very strong tequila. Others will use barrels that once held various, sherry, bourbon, scotch and even Bordeaux wine. The resulting extra anejo tequilas have a depth and complexity that cannot be duplicated in any other way. For people who appreciate the intricacies of a sophisticated taste, extra anejo tequila offers no peer. Each Extra Anejo Tequila is recognized for its uniquely complex flavor complete with the woody notes that come from the barrels in which it aged. Extra Anejo frequently boasts a long finish and buttery agave flavor.

The Ways People Drink Extra Anejo Tequila

Neat.  That's it.  I won't even write any other way to drink this expression or give anyone ideas because it's simply not the play.  Don't drink this any other way than neat in a nice sipping glass.

My List of the Best Extra Anejo Tequilas for 2021

This is my list, yours may vary and of course like anything else in life, there will be debates. I highly encourage you to share your favorites in the comments section.

#1:  Tears of Llorona

tears of llorona extra anejo tequila
The color of this tequila is spectacular.

Read the Tears of Llorona review to find out why it tops my list as the best extra anejo tequila.

#2:  San Matias Rey Sol  

rey sol extra anejo tequila

I'm currently anticipating a delivery of the Rey Sol 20 year anniversary tequila. 

#3: Jose Cuervo Reserva de la Familia

jose cuervo reserva de la familia

#4:  Seleccion Suprema de Herradura

seleccion suprema herradura

#5:  El Tesoro Paradiso Extra Anejo

el tesoro paradiso

I'll be adding more color to these selections as well as written and video reviews, so stay tuned for that while I get organized.  You can't go wrong with anything on that list.

I'll go on record saying I haven't had any of the Tequila Ocho in this expression, and their Anejo expressions are among my favorites, so I will most likely be adding this to the list soon if I can sample it.  There is also a Cazcanes extremely limited release I just got this Spring, which isn't far from my top five list, in addition to the Maestro Dobel 1968 I haven't opened.

Please share with us your thoughts and takes on this list in the comments below! 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *